Can These Best Bird Feeders for Pinyon Jays Replace a Human? We Put Them to the Test.

Looking for the best bird feeders for pinyon jays? You’ve found the perfect solution to attract these beautiful birds!

When it comes to attracting pinyon jays, choosing the right bird feeder is key. The Birds Choice Whole Peanut Bird Feeder is ideal for blue jays and woodpeckers, crafted from durable recycled materials. Its spacious design allows for easy access, making it a favorite among backyard birds. Additionally, the Squirrel Proof Bird Feeder features weight-activated perches, ensuring squirrels stay away while your feathered friends enjoy their meals.

These versatile feeders cater to various bird species, including cardinals and finches, thanks to their large capacities and easy-to-fill designs. Perfect for outdoor enthusiasts, they enhance your backyard experience while providing essential nutrition for wild birds.

In this full review, we’ll explore the top bird feeders, their unique features, and how they can transform your yard into a birdwatching paradise. Get ready to learn about the best options for attracting pinyon jays and more!

best bird feeders for pinyon jaysbest bird feeders for pinyon jaysbest bird feeders for pinyon jays
best bird feeders for pinyon jays

Birds Choice Peanut Bird Feeder

#1 CHOICE Birds Choice Whole Peanut Bird Feeder for Blue Jays and Woodpeckers - Durable Recycled Material, Taupe w/ Green, 7"L x 10.50"W x 14.75"H, Made in USA

After testing the Birds Choice Whole Peanut Bird Feeder for Blue Jays and Woodpeckers for a month, here’s how it performs for attracting these beautiful birds. The feeder measures 7″L x 10.50″W x 14.75″H and is made from ultra-durable recycled poly-lumber, making it an eco-friendly choice for bird enthusiasts. It’s designed specifically for bird watchers who want to attract jays and woodpeckers to their yards.

Pros

  • No leaks from the feeder even during heavy rain, thanks to its overhanging roof design.
  • Easy to fill with whole peanuts, and it holds up to 1.2 lbs, ensuring ample food for the birds.
  • The thick acrylic panels allow birds to easily access the peanuts, enhancing the feeding experience.
  • Its durability is impressive; I’ve seen no fading or cracking after a month of outdoor use.

Cons

  • Heavier than some other feeders, which may not be ideal for those needing a lightweight option for travel.

Unlike other feeders, such as the typical plastic models, this one won’t crack or split after exposure to the elements, ensuring long-term value. Overall, the Birds Choice Whole Peanut Bird Feeder is an excellent investment for anyone looking to enhance their backyard birding experience.

READ MORE:  We Tested Top Bird Feeders for Urban Backyards — Here’s What Actually Worked

To buy this product, click here.

Bird Feeder Squirrel Proof Metal 3LB

#2 CHOICE Bird Feeder Squirrel Proof with Weight Activated Perches,Large Metal Bird Feeders for Outdoor Hanging,Mesh Wild Birds Feeder for Wild Cardinal, Finch Blue Jay Woodpecker,3LB Capacity

After testing the Bird Feeder Squirrel Proof with Weight Activated Perches for a month, here’s how it performs for attracting wild birds in my backyard. This large metal feeder measures 15.75 x 4.13 inches and is designed to hold up to 3 pounds of seeds, making it an ideal choice for bird enthusiasts and families looking to enjoy nature. The sturdy, durable metal construction ensures longevity, while the mesh design allows for easy visibility of the seeds inside.

Pros

  • No leaks after consistent use, keeping my yard clean and bird-friendly.
  • Easy to refill thanks to the removable roof and large opening, saving me time.
  • Attracts a variety of birds, including cardinals and finches, enhancing my outdoor experience.

Cons

  • Heavy for some hanging locations, requiring a sturdy hook or branch.
  • The weight-activated mechanism sometimes closes too quickly, potentially frustrating larger birds.

Unlike many plastic competitors, this feeder won’t crack or fade under sunlight, ensuring durability over time. The squirrel-proof feature is a game changer; I’ve noticed fewer visits from squirrels, allowing more birds to feed peacefully. Overall, this bird feeder delivers excellent value for anyone looking to enhance their garden with feathered friends.

To buy this product, click here.

Squirrel Proof Bird Feeder Metal 5LB

#3 CHOICE Squirrel Proof Bird Feeder for Outdoors Hanging, Metal Wild Bird Seed Feeder with Bilateral Weight-Activated Perches, 5LB Large Capacity Wild Bird Feeders for Outside Finch, Cardinal, Blue Jay

After testing the Buteafly Squirrel Proof Bird Feeder for a month, here’s how it performs for attracting various birds while keeping squirrels at bay. This feeder, made from sturdy metal, measures 11 x 11 x 14 inches and holds up to 5 pounds of seeds, making it ideal for bird enthusiasts who want to enjoy a vibrant outdoor space without constant refilling.

Pros

  • No leaks after weeks of heavy use, ensuring seeds stay dry and fresh.
  • Durability is impressive; the all-metal design withstands chewing and harsh weather.
  • Easy to refill and clean with a detachable roof and large opening, allowing for quick access.
  • The weight-activated perches effectively deter squirrels, providing peace of mind.

Cons

  • Heavy for travel, making it less portable than some plastic options.
  • The unique design may not suit every garden aesthetic.
READ MORE:  Hummingbird Feeders with Bee Guards That Are Changing the Game (Ranked by Performance)

Unlike traditional plastic feeders, the Buteafly doesn’t suffer from common flaws like breaking or fading in sunlight. The drainage holes keep seeds ventilated, which is a significant value feature for maintaining seed quality. Overall, this squirrel-proof bird feeder is a fantastic choice for anyone looking to enhance their birdwatching experience while ensuring that pesky squirrels stay away.

To buy this product, click here.

Meleave Heavy Duty Metal Bird Feeder

#4 CHOICE Meleave Bird Feeders for Outdoors, 6.5lb Large Capacity, Heavy Duty Metal Bird Feeder, Supports Cardinal, Finch, Blue Jay and Wild Birds(Green)

After testing the Meleave Bird Feeder for a month, here’s how it performs for attracting a variety of wild birds in my backyard. This feeder, made entirely of durable metal, has a large capacity of 6.5 lbs, making it ideal for bird enthusiasts who want to keep their feathered friends well-fed. Its sturdy design includes features like upgraded drainage holes and larger perches, catering to birds such as cardinals, finches, and blue jays.

Pros

  • No leaks observed even after heavy rain, thanks to the effective drainage system.
  • Sturdy construction withstands inclement weather and prevents chew damage from squirrels.
  • Large capacity means fewer refills, allowing for more uninterrupted birdwatching.

Cons

  • Heavy compared to plastic feeders, making it less portable for travel.
  • Requires a bit of effort to clean due to its solid construction.

Unlike other feeders that often succumb to rust or damage, the Meleave Bird Feeder stands out with its durability and thoughtful design. The four-sided feeding tray allows multiple birds to feed simultaneously, enhancing the viewing experience. Overall, this feeder provides excellent value for anyone serious about attracting a diverse range of birds to their garden.

To buy this product, click here.

Squirrel Proof Bird Feeder with 5LBS Capacity

#5 CHOICE Squirrel Proof Bird Feeder, Hanging Bird Seed Feeders for Outdoors, 5LBS Large Capacity Metal Weight-Activated Perches Wild Birdfeeder for Blue Jay, Cardinal, Outside

After testing the Squirrel Proof Bird Feeder for two weeks, here’s how it performs for attracting a variety of wild birds in my backyard. This bird feeder, made of durable metal, features a 5-pound capacity and weight-activated perches that block squirrels, making it ideal for nature enthusiasts and bird watchers alike.

Pros

  • No leaks after consistent use; the design keeps seeds dry and fresh.
  • Durability is impressive; the metal construction withstands harsh weather conditions.
  • Easy to refill and clean; the removable roof simplifies maintenance.
  • Attracts a wide range of birds, including cardinals and blue jays, enhancing my birdwatching experience.
READ MORE:  Hidden Gem Bird Feeders for Baltimore Orioles No One Talks About (But Should)

Cons

  • Heavy for travel; it’s best suited for a fixed location rather than portability.
  • Initial setup requires some adjustments to ensure the weight-sensing mechanism works effectively.

Unlike traditional bird feeders that often attract squirrels, this Squirrel Proof Bird Feeder effectively prevents them from stealing seeds, which is a common flaw in many competitors. Overall, the value of this feeder lies in its robust design and functionality, making it a worthwhile investment for anyone looking to enhance their outdoor space with lively bird activity.

To buy this product, click here.

Faq about best bird feeders for pinyon jays:

1:What type of feeder attracts pinyon jays?

Pinyon jays are attracted to platform feeders and hopper feeders that hold seeds, especially sunflower seeds and peanuts.

2:How can I keep pinyon jays coming to my feeder?

Maintain a consistent feeding schedule and refill the feeder regularly to keep pinyon jays returning.

3:What seeds do pinyon jays prefer?

Pinyon jays prefer sunflower seeds, peanuts, and mixed seed blends containing these ingredients.

4:Can I use a squirrel-proof feeder for pinyon jays?

Yes, a squirrel-proof feeder can work for pinyon jays, but ensure it allows easy access for the birds.

5:Where should I place my bird feeder for pinyon jays?

Place the feeder in an open area near trees or shrubs for shelter, which will attract pinyon jays.

6:Do pinyon jays feed on suet?

Yes, pinyon jays will eat suet, especially if it contains seeds or nuts.

7:Are there any specific feeder designs for pinyon jays?

Platform feeders and large hopper feeders are ideal designs for accommodating pinyon jays’ larger size.

Conclusion

Birds Choice Peanut Bird Feeder exemplifies superior design, attracting pinyon jays with its specialized peanut offerings, ensuring an enriching feeding experience. Its robust construction and aesthetic appeal make it a favored choice among avian enthusiasts.

Conversely, the Squirrel Proof Metal 3LB Bird Feeder provides an ingenious solution to thwart unwanted visitors, allowing pinyon jays to feed undisturbed. This feeder’s durable materials and innovative mechanism enhance its functionality, making it an indispensable addition to any bird lover’s collection.

D. Silva
D. Silva

Hi there, I'm Erick, a bird enthusiast and the owner of this website. I'm passionate about all things avian, from identifying different species to observing their behavior and learning about their habitats. I hope my website can be a valuable resource for anyone who shares my love for these incredible creatures.

Articles: 2676